Choosing the right siding material is a big decision. We break down the pros, cons, cost, and durability of vinyl and fiber cement so you can choose with confidence.
When it comes to replacing your home's siding, two materials dominate the conversation: vinyl and fiber cement. Both have their strengths, and the right choice depends on your budget, aesthetic preferences, and how long you plan to stay in your home. Here's an honest breakdown from our team.
Vinyl siding has been America's most popular siding choice for decades, and for good reason. It's affordable, comes in a huge variety of colors and styles, and requires virtually no maintenance beyond an occasional power wash. Modern vinyl has come a long way from the thin, flimsy panels of the past — today's premium vinyl is thicker, more realistic, and more durable.
The main drawbacks? Vinyl can crack in extreme cold, fade over time with prolonged sun exposure, and doesn't add as much to your home's resale value as fiber cement. It also can't be painted — once you choose a color, you're stuck with it unless you replace the panels. (See our color picks for 2026.)
Fiber cement siding — with James Hardie being the most well-known brand — is made from a mix of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. It's incredibly durable, fire-resistant, and can mimic the look of wood, stucco, or stone. It holds paint beautifully and can be repainted whenever you want a fresh look.
The trade-offs are higher upfront cost (roughly 2–3x the price of vinyl installed) and heavier weight, which means installation takes longer and requires more labor. It also needs to be repainted every 10–15 years to maintain its appearance.
For most Indiana homeowners, we recommend vinyl siding for its unbeatable value and ease of maintenance. If you're building your forever home or want maximum curb appeal and resale value, fiber cement is worth the investment. Either way, proper installation is what matters most — and that's where our siding installation team shines.
Visit our showroom to see and feel samples of both materials, or book a free siding consultation and we'll bring samples to you. You can also call us at (260) 248-0210.
The best siding colors for Indiana homes — How new siding can cut your energy bills — Our siding services overview — Get a free siding estimate
Get a free, no-obligation estimate from Northern Indiana's most trusted contractor.